I bought a lot of eleven Michael Jordan cover magazines on Facebook Marketplace. The seller turned out to be the owner of Amazing Collectibles Orlando near downtown on South Bumby — so the pickup became my first walk through the shop. Nice surprise.
Service: 9.2. Todd and his wife Tori were there. Super nice. Greeters who actually help — where to look, what is where — without hovering. That alone beats a lot of shops that treat walk-ins like inventory theft risks.
Atmosphere: 6.5. Small. A little messy. Cards being sorted. That is how real card shops often look, and I am fine with it — it is not a polished LCS showroom. Slabs in one zone, raw in another, packs and boxes stacked, plus antiques and other collectibles mixed in. Sports cards still felt predominant.
Price: 9.0. Prices looked really good. I did not buy anything beyond the magazine lot I already had coming, but I saw a few things I liked and the tags did not scare me off.
Selection: 6.8. Fine for a browse. Not stacked with the chase stuff I asked about. I asked on unique Cardinals — he did not think they had any. They were kind of out of Jordan card inventory too. Magazines yes. Deep team hits no — at least not on this visit.
Knup 7.0 / 10. Nothing amazing, nothing bad. Great owners, strong prices, everyday shop footprint. Easy five stars on Google for the experience. I will come back when I am hunting something specific — and when I do, selection will decide whether this climbs.
Photos
Visits
-
September 22, 2026
FB Marketplace pickup: 11 MJ cover magazines from owner Todd. First visit. Met Todd + Tori. Looked but did not buy cards.
Google review draft (5.0★) — copy when you post:
Picked up a Facebook Marketplace lot of Michael Jordan cover magazines from the owner and got to walk Amazing Collectibles Orlando for the first time. Todd and Tori were super welcoming — greeted me right away and pointed me where to look. Classic small card shop vibe: a little messy while sorting, slabs in one area, raw in another, packs and boxes everywhere, plus antiques and other collectibles beyond sports. Prices looked really strong. Selection was more everyday than chase-worthy for what I asked about (Cardinals / Jordan), but the hospitality and value made it an easy five stars. Happy I ended up here for the pickup.